Old noob question but

[blackmage_nuke]

It's that damn trial in ct, Ive checked a few different walkthroughs and the forums, but i cant see what i forgot to do, there's one guy who saying im guilty

I remember I gave the girl her cat
Didnt eat the guy's lunch
Waited for the candy
Didnt sell the pendant to Melchior (but i did talk to him)
Talked to her before taking the pendant

I said i started it and wasnt tempted by her riches twice
But that guy still says im guilty, if it helps, it's the second guy who says it.

What did i do?!

Edit: lol abit off topic, but when i escaped after the guard came in to rough me up, instead of whacking him on the back of the head i walk right in front of him and owned him in the face.