Define the "FF Experience"...

[,,,]

The most important one of all-- fun to play. FVII and FFII failed. But that doesn't mean they aren't FFs, just that they suck.

Um, no, they failed (and suck) to you. Probably more people than not would disagree with that statement about VII so to say in general that it failed is a fallacy.

People in Kanno's "unreasonably disliked" thread also say that II was a fun game (including myself) so again, remember that it's just your personal opinion.

Uh yeah, that was the point of the thread.

"What is the "FF Experience" to you?"

So yes, the "to me" is what I was answering. To me, those games failed miserably to provide me with fun and, therefore, suck.