metacritic.com/games
gamerankings.com
type in Enchanted Arms and see the average of critical and user reviews. The game wasn't too important really. I think it got more attention because it was the first traditional rpg for the Xbox 360 and also for the PS 3. If you want to you can rent it, but I don't recommend buying it without playing it.

Somehow, I'm reminded of the situation we had in the Fall of 1996 I think when the first rpg for PS 1 came out and it was Beyond The Beyond and it wasn't too good. Some people skipped it and waited 2-3 months because that's when Suikoden 1 and Persona 1 came out, which were both pretty good games.

Release Dates