Mafia - Second Edition - Game Over!

[[M] Caprica]

Robin Hood

Anyone who has any thoughts of the last game in their mind when playing this one is stupid. The last game should have absolutely no relevance to this one whatsoever, completely different set of people, roles and characters.



Also find it amusing that people are saying "Well X has done this like Y did last time and Y was a mafia, therefore X is mafia as well". In case you've all forgotten, the mafia last time lost, quite severely, and if you're all going to underestimate the mafia to be so stupid as to do what the last ones did, then you're on route to a hiding.

See, Robin Hood? That's how you make a critique on someone's reasoning. You don't use it as a veil to vote for them. (SORRY IF YOU TAKE THIS AS A PERSONAL ATTACK )

Criticism accepted, Chip.

I said the exact same thing:

It's too easy to say, "Person XYZ is behaving just like mafia member ABC from last game." For someone that's complaining about riding a bandwagon, this is a very similar strategy/action. Personally, I would like all accusations be be founded on actions and activities solely from this game. Since mafia can choose to or not choose to act a certain way, or act just like previous mafioso, there is no way to accertain if someone's actions in this game pin them as mafia because of how someone acted a game before. This accusation based on historical activities seems like a red herring,