Mafia - Second Edition - Game Over!

[[M] Eizen]

Peter Pan

Oh, wow, it's all happening now.

I've been contacted by four members directly now (three if you exclude Hercules) and know that one of the people has included another in one method of contact and another member has advised me that they are in contact with one other person and know of another person's innocence.

But let's put it this way. Party A told me to vote for Party B. Party C is asking me who to vote for rather than the other way around, but they also suspect Party B. Party B has told me a variety of their conclusions but 2 parties vs. 1 party... well, I don't think it's very likely that TWO mafia would contact me. Uuuuurrrrrrgh this is confusing. All said and done, I'm going to go with my instincts based on posts I read BEFORE the contact was made, so here we go. *deep breath* I hope this doesn't screw me over because I'm going to vote for one of the groups that contacted me. If they turn out to be a citizen then I'll at least take that into account next time.

---//---

Herc, you served us well - two votes, two mafia dead.

Hrmm, bugger. I'd have rather it had been someone I wasn't sure on. But them's the breaks, I suppose.

I haven't too much of an idea on who to go for this time. I highly doubt the mafia would make the same mistake three times in a row (although you never know o_o), let alone being able to be picked up. The upside though is that we have a load of information from the previous day to work on thanks to the discussions that went on.

One thing that I can say is that I checked with Levian and the Godfather would NOT have been aware that the usurper was an usurper, he would have thought he was a regular mafia. With that in mind, it would have been likely that they wouldn't have made the deciding vote. It was probably one of the earlier people, and more than likely someone who didn't vote the first time. So. I think this is right, correct me if I'm wrong, but this is the chronological order of votes, unvotes, etc.

Cinderella: Mickey 1
Pluto: Mickey 2
Hercules: Dale 1
Bambi: Dale 2
Winnie: Mickey 3
Peter: Cinderella 1
Aladdin: Pinnochio 1
Chip: Bambi 1
Baloo: Buzz 1
Bambi: UNVOTE Dale (1)
Bambi: Cinderella 2
Quasimodo: Cinderella 3
Robin: Cinderella 4
Buzz: Cinderella 5
Alice: Pluto 1
Buzz: UNVOTE Cinderella (4)
Hercules: UNVOTE Dale (1)
Buzz: Cinderella 5
Cinderella reveals she is an usurper
Hercules: Cinderella 6
Dumbo: Cinderella 7

I don't suspect myself, obviously. If people wonder why I do so much, it's because I'm a regular citizen and I'll point out as much as I can about everyone I find slightly suspicious, because, well, that's all I'm able to do. I'm not a cop or a doc or whatever else there might be, so if I die eventually, so be it. Killing two mafia along the way reads success to me.

Bambi latched on to my vote for Cinderella pretty damned fast, and it didn't put Cinderella on even terms with Mickey at that point. Bambi has also added not much to our conversations, it has to be said. However, look at post #193 carefully. In this post, Bambi quotes Cinderella. Cinderella is saying first that Bambi is the Jester, and that we should vote for him. Surely voting for the Jester knowing it's the Jester is bad? So why would he want Bambi dead? Let's look at the rest. "We all know the newbie who doesn't understand the game thing is an act, and I was happy to go along with it while you were keeping it up" - sound likes a mafia member talking to his boss, doesn't it? 'Going along with it' and all. "but now you're turning on me, smurf you, I'll do the same back to you." - ...but now the Godfather is turning on the mafia member? He'll do the same to you? Maybe.

Quasimodo really pushed for the death of Cinderella while I was too lazy to log in and didn't stop. I don't suspect Quasi so much. Not to mention that Quasi put Cinderella into the dangerous position of tied with Mickey.

I don't suspect Robin as much because 1) Robin could have gone out in the first round with his own mafia encouraging people to vote for him, and 2) Robin pushed Cinderella into the lead and if Robin WAS the Godfather, Robin would have known he was putting another mafia into his deathbed. I really don't think the mafia can afford to do that kind of thing, especially after one had already died so early in the game.

Buzz is an iffy one, really. Cinderella was already looking to be dead at that point anyway, so if he was Godfather he might have just gone for her to make himself look safe. What's more, he unvoted Cinderella, possibly a ploy to encourage others to do the same. Of course, the moment he re-voted for Cinderella she revealed she was an usurper. I think there are reasons for suspicion, but certainly nothing close to the reasons to suspect Bambi. Bambi also backed herself up the least, and we need people who are going to back themselves up. Otherwise you never know what you're going to end up with...

Vote: Bambi

This is arse tough. I'm wishing the cops would help out but I'm sure they're on the job...

Still, that's my decision for this round and I don't see myself changing it but the more I know the more I might be able to, but I need good reasons. What are the odds on getting three in a row? xD Probably crap.

---//---

Sorry Bambi if you are innocent. This was a massively tough call. The only alternative is to go for someone who is deciding to lay low. But personally I think that if someone dramatically changes their strategy the moment they die... well, that's suspicious, too. If you're a doctor, then this is super arse, but with all this new information it's tough. I'm going to have to think more, but we'll see. The above was all typed out before I logged in as Peter Pan, though (everything inside the --//-- bits anyway). Now it seems the Party A is no longer wanting to vote for Party B. I do wonder how many mafia might be trying to manipulate me, though. This game is so a;oihgapoweighaw sometimes.

EDIT: If Resha was telling you what to say, though, then that makes things much more interesting. What I'd like to know is why you were listening to someone else without knowing who they were. Because you're not a cop, as you said, you're a doctor... but for some reason you trust Simba and you took on the strategy of doing whatever someone else says? I'll keep my vote s Bambi for those reasons.

EDIT AGAIN: I'm a citizen. If I get this wrong, and you guys want to kill me, then it's of no loss to the citizens when it comes to cops and doctors. Just so you guys know. So if Bambi is actually a doctor and I kill her, I'm okay with you killing me because I'll feel like an utter failure anyway ;(

EDIT: This is really bugging me now. I unvote Bambi until further notice.

UNVOTE: Bambi.