Mafia - Second Edition - Game Over!

[[M] Ron - Cop Dad]

Pluto

After reading through this thread I no longer suspect Mickey. Cindy was really pushing for Mickey and Mickey helped lead us to Dale. Those two things are good enough for me. Sorry Mickster for the trouble earlier.

I want to make clear that the post where I said I still suspected Mickey was before I read all the Cinderella mess. That was a lot of mess. At least I voted for the right person.

I believe Cinderella's list. I think the godfather is on it. Psy had Dale and I think at least one other mafia member to still win it for him. Near the end he was telling the truth about his role so that is points for him. However, the town doesn't seem to want to go after those people at this time. At some point we do need to test that list.

What do we know? We KNOW there is the godfather still out there. We KNOW that Cinderella wants that person dead. We don't know that there are any other mafia besides the godfather left, though it is likely. There are 22 characters in this game. There are at least 4 mafia. Last time there were 22 people and only 4 mafia. For that reason I don't think there are 6 or more mafia. Could only be four, could be five. If there are 4 then only the godfather is left. If 5 then there is one more than the godfather. However, there are at least one cop left in this game. The cop can find the mysterious 5th mafia if they exist, but they cannot find the godfather.

I think we should start to focus on the godfather. There were five people on 'The List'. I now put it up to the town to determine if we should focus on those five or continue with suspicions of other members. I do agree that Alice and Winnie are suspicious for reasons already stated, but if they are mafia the cops can find out. Maybe they already have and are trying to sway us now. I don't know.

Unfortunately my situation prevents me from being on the forums for large chunks of the day, so I will have to make my vote later tonight.