It may be fun for those doing the colluding, but not for those who are not involved. If you are not part of the secret cliques that have all these discussions then the main thread becomes very confusing and it makes it hard to base your vote off anything. This way it can be eually enjoyable for everyone. Besides, this is how it's done in pretty much every other online version of this game, and in the offline version there is no way you can collude because you are all sitting together the whole time. This is what mafia is.
We had two rounds of it that way, now it's time to try it this way. Don't play if you don't like the rules, but they aren't changing.
