Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-11-2008 at 08:29 PM.
Cubone is DEAD. You can't lynch a dead person. I mean, you can but that's pretty messed up.
Last edited by Miriel; 12-01-2007 at 04:19 AM.
Eevee
Yeah, we actually have nobody to base our suspicions on. Not even people being suspiciously quiet, since it's just the first day, and people might not be around right now, or whatever. It's a difficult lynch, this one.
Not to mention we can't really take a big guess at a member, because if they turn out to be citizen, you'll be immediately targetted for targetting a citizen. It really is difficult.
Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-24-2008 at 08:33 PM.
Psyduck
Psyduck Psy!.. i dont mean that.. i just dont know if ill be around when they choose who gets lynched.. Psyayay *sad*
Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-11-2008 at 08:29 PM.
First day is just guesswork. Assuming there's six mafia members like last time, we have a 6/22 chance of getting one. That's around 27%. We could get really lucky, but no one's willing to take the chance to vote yet because it's more likely that they'll be wrong and will have to face being lynched the next day for their mistake. We can sit and wait and lynch no one, but that will only be a mafia advantage since they can strike us down at night. Bottom line is that we have to make a decision, even if it's a complete guess.
Psyduck
but we are at the most disadvantage now.. mafia know who they are.. so they will all vote to lynch someone else.. and the rest of us dont know who who is.. so we will just go with their votes.. so i suggest we dont lynch.. cause the statistics are just against us
if you guys really want to.. i suggest butterfree *narows eyes at butterfree*
Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-11-2008 at 08:29 PM.
We can't not lynch someone.
Why Butterfree? Is there any real reason behind this?
Vulpix
If no one votes, we will never be able to deduce who the mafia are by their voting patterns. Mafia probably aren't going to draw attention to themselves by lynching a citizen if no one else is voting at all, because they can kill us one by one at night. Citizen numbers will go down, Mafia will remain stagnant. We lose.
Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-11-2008 at 08:40 PM.
I don't think we should go for Butterfree. Butterfree is at least being active and posting. We need everyone to be active and posting, because posts are all we've got to work on.
Jigglypuff and Diglett are the only ones who haven't posted in this thread or the other mafia thread yet.
Eevee
Sometimes people aren't around. The inactivity vote can be bad.
Perhaps Squirtle, who posted in the Discussion thread, and not this thread? Even though this thread was open!
Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-24-2008 at 08:33 PM.
Slowpoke
*wakes up from his long snooze*
We should lynch Psyduck for putting me to sleep and causing my inactivity.
Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-24-2008 at 08:16 PM.
Psyduck
Psyayay!
snot my fault.. i was just trying to talk to you, slooooooooooooooowpoke
you cant blame me just because your tail is bigger
Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-11-2008 at 08:30 PM.
Kadabra
As Vulpix said, today will be pretty random. We just have to pick someone not based on suspiciousness, because there's simply no one to suspect at this point. I'm in favor of lynching someone unactive. Why? Because they have just as high chance of being Mafia as anyone else, probably a bit more since Mafia doesn't want to draw attention to themselves, but most importantly; if they're a doc and they don't log in for 14 hours, then they won't be of any use anyway.
Chances are we're going to lynch an innocent citizen today, though. At least whatever happens today is valuable information tomorrow.
Last edited by qwertysaur; 11-24-2008 at 08:46 PM.