Alright here is what I'm thinking so far...

Psyduck- I'm a bit suspicious toward him, because he called out our cop, which is a move a mafia player might make to try and get him killed during the night... But there is also a possibility that he did that because he is new to the game and doesn't know how to play real well...

Vulpix- Out of all the characters so far, I'd be surprised if he was scum.

Slowpoke- I have a theory toward him. I don't think he's mafia, I think he's a citizen that just doesn't realize what kind of game this is. I think he's trying to steal some glory by sticking with all of his claims, and being way over dramatic.

Togepi- Just got here. Can't say much.

Charmander- I don't know if he's mafia, but he is definitely following, I'd like to hear his opinion for once.

Kadabra- To be totally honest... I DON'T EVEN KNOW ANYMORE!?! This situation with Kadabra has gone nuts! I can't call him a Mafian because of a few contradictions that I got from Slowpoke's half-baked ideas, but there's been so much suspicion around him its hard to call him a Citizen either.

Squirtle- He's pointed a lot of finger without saying anything, I've defended him, but I'm still weary.

Clafairy- No problems so far, but thats because I haven't seen many posts by him/her so far.

EDIT: Vampires? WTF? What the hell are they?