Pokemon Mafia - Official Game Thread (On hold)

[[M] Dee]

Eevee

After looking through roles... Cops can only see whether someone is citizen or mafia, not whether they are a werewolf. So... how can you be sure he's a werewolf, if according to this cops can only tell whether someone is mafia or not?

Unless I've misunderstood this. Or there's not both mafia and werewolves. *shrug*

[[M] Harry - Dad's Dad]

Psyduck

i think there are only wherewolves..

however i shall join you in shrugging *shrugs*

Psyduck! Psyayay!! Duck!

just had to get that out of my system

[[M] Mom – Host]

Slowpoke

Mafia (also known as Werewolf or Vampire)



-I got that from the Mafia wiki. Also the wiki talks about mafia talking to eachother during night and such...Which is also another reason I assumed there were more werewolves.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Mafia (also known as Werewolf or Vampire)

-I got that from the Mafia wiki.

*starts the slow clap*

[[M] D'Anna]

Kadabra

It's not that I'm a lucky cop, it's that I'm a smart cop who investigated the person who made mistakes and revealed his mafianess by bieng so tied together with butterfree. You made a mistake to be so together with butterfree and lie so much.

First of all, I'm tied together with Butterfree? We haven't done anything to link us together. You sure have the guts to throw out the word lie hundreds of times. I have no idea how many times you've called me a liar in this thread.

I have no reason to kill him if I weren't a cop and knew he was a werewolf.

Why did you accuse me on Day 1 then? When you hadn't even investigated me yet. :rolleyes2

who else would go 100%sure and promise to be lynched if the other isn't what he says he is?
-Only a cop is capable of that.

No, a liar can easily do that too.

If for some reason you shouldn't turn out a Mafia, then I don't mind the citizen lynching me either, because I'm pretty damn sure you are one! Why else would you attack me so furiously for no reason when you hadn't even "investigated" me yet?

[[M] Mom – Host]

Slowpoke

It's not that I'm a lucky cop, it's that I'm a smart cop who investigated the person who made mistakes and revealed his mafianess by bieng so tied together with butterfree. You made a mistake to be so together with butterfree and lie so much.

First of all, I'm tied together with Butterfree? We haven't done anything to link us together. You sure have the guts to throw out the word lie hundreds of times. I have no idea how many times you've called me a liar in this thread.

I have no reason to kill him if I weren't a cop and knew he was a werewolf.

Why did you accuse me on Day 1 then? When you hadn't even investigated me yet. :rolleyes2

who else would go 100%sure and promise to be lynched if the other isn't what he says he is?
-Only a cop is capable of that.

No, a liar can easily do that too.

If for some reason you shouldn't turn out a Mafia, then I don't mind the citizen lynching me either, because I'm pretty damn sure you are one! Why else would you attack me so furiously for no reason when you hadn't even "investigated" me yet?

I simply suggested your suspiscions in day 1 so that if I investigate you and were right, I could convince people that you were a werewolf with the seed I had already planted without having to reveal my identity. but so far the towns mistrust in me has got me out in the open. but as long as I can get you killed, I'm confident I can find someone else I have strong suspicions for. and also if your killed, the proof of your werewolf bieng might help me have a town that trusts me.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Why else would you attack me so furiously for no reason when you hadn't even "investigated" me yet?

Beacause he is the lyncher and you are the lynchee

[[M] Mom – Host]

Slowpoke

Why else would you attack me so furiously for no reason when you hadn't even "investigated" me yet?

Beacause he is the lyncher and you are the lynchee

well that...and because I was trying to make it possible, after investigating Kadabra, I could prove his guilt without having to reveal myself.

that's another reason I attacked you so furiously as well. A cop's goal in the beginning is to get mafia lynched without having to reveal himself just yet.

[[M] Harry - Dad's Dad]

Psyduck

maybe we should just ask for a list of jobs used.. i mean that isnt against the rules.. it should be in the rulezz.. i mean there could be a chinese food guy for all we know

so which jobs are used administrators?

[[M] Ron - Cop Dad]

My opinion on this.

I believe one of them is telling the truth.

At the moment I'm leaning toward Slowpoke... Because according to the Mafia Wiki, the mafia may also be called Werewolves. If this is true then Kadabra's role would be ficticious. One problem, how do we know Del and Mirel didn't make their own rules and branch off?

We don't.

We have to Lynch one, because one of them is lying. At the moment I vote we lynch Kadabra. Because if we lynch him and he is mafia then we know that we have our cop, who he is, and we're Good. If we find out Mafia isn't scum, we know exactly who to lynch next.

Why trust Slowpoke right now? Cop is important, if he's telling the truth and we lynch him, we may as well have shot ourselves in the foot.

[[M] D'Anna]

Kadabra

I know what a cop does. You attacked me furiously before you investigated me. That's my point.

And what? you're admitting to being the Lyncher? Then that really settles it. You'll be one of the winners of the game if I'm lynched before you die, so then it's really in everyone's best interest to not lynch me today.

[[M] Harry - Dad's Dad]

Psyduck

My opinion on this.

I believe one of them is telling the truth.

At the moment I'm leaning toward Slowpoke... Because according to the Mafia Wiki, the mafia may also be called Werewolves. If this is true then Kadabra's role would be ficticious. One problem, how do we know Del and Mirel didn't make their own rules and branch off?

We don't.

We have to Lynch one, because one of them is lying. At the moment I vote we lynch Kadabra. Because if we lynch him and he is mafia then we know that we have our cop, who he is, and we're Good. If we find out Mafia isn't scum, we know exactly who to lynch next.

Why trust Slowpoke right now? Cop is important, if he's telling the truth and we lynch him, we may as well have shot ourselves in the foot.

youd still have me..

PSYDUCK TO THE RESQUE

*trips over his own tail*

Psyayay!! *rubs tail*

[[M] Dee]

Eevee

Back Up Cops can only investigate once though, according to the Mafia Wiki.

[[M] Ron - Cop Dad]

Back Up Cops can only investigate once though, according to the Mafia Wiki.

Which is why I'd prefer to be safe instead of sorry.

But this is a personal opinion. And hell maybe you guys can sway it.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Slowpoke

I know what a cop does. You attacked me furiously before you investigated me. That's my point.

And what? you're admitting to being the Lyncher? Then that really settles it. You'll be one of the winners of the game if I'm lynched before you die, so then it's really in everyone's best interest to not lynch me today.

I attacked you before I investigated you because that attack, was to hopefully be able to lynch you without revealing that I'm a cop. If I had suspicion before, and had gone along with that the Mafia would have no reason to believe I'm a cop I would be able to investigate at night while safe.

The whole point of not bieng found out as a cop is, so that you can have more safe nights, which are very needed because alot of times cops just investigate citizens. but I think I got a mafia and not citizien, because you slipped up in the beginning, on top of us getting lucky with butterfree.