They gave Xenosaga III a 3/5 simply because they didn't like the long cutscenes.
God knows what they think of Final Fantasy. I am pretty sure most scenes in FFVIII alone are quit ea bit longer than anything in XSIII.
Plus they like to throw in personal attacks, that's what they want someone who cosplays FF for.
"When was the last time you got laid?"
(doesn't give him time to answer*
"Does it make you feel cool to pretend to be a lame emo with spikey hair, weird biceps and an overly large sword? You play "Pretend" a lot?"
Not that I cosplay but I really don't care if other people do it. And I certainly wouldn't bring it into a debate about the merits of the FF franchise. But Adam and Morgan would.