Mafia V: Official game thread (Day 7 - Game Over. Town Win!)

[[M] Kurt - Cool Dad]

Faris:

Why indeed? It would be a really dumb move for the mafia to make, so dumb we would never suspect them of doing it. Which makes it brilliant.

Mind you, I don't think you're a part of it just yet, Ramza.

Theory: Edgar and Ingus are BOTH mafia. They planned their little argument from the beginning. Notice how they eventually took their votes off each other and moved right for Barret? It all seemed very theatrical. After all that, why would we still suspect them? It would be foolish to think mafia would come out so early. Nice try! And even if we did kill off one, this little argument could 'prove' their innocence for a long while, making the other very safe.

It would be a risky move, with a potential great reward. Mafia needs to take risks if they want to win, as the odds are very much against them.

What do you all think?

Awww I was saving that theory to play out later.

But yeah that was one deduction I got from the banter early. It's easily solved though, we lynch one of them and if their mafia then go us. If we lynch who they try to veer suspicion too then not a whole lot can be said. If we lynched a mafia because of who they say is suspicious it could just be a ploy to make us trust in them. If it's a townie then they could just be stabbing in the dark as well, or be mafia trying to kill us off.

Looking at everything I say the best option is to lynch Ingus, Edgar, or one other low profile suspicious person.