Mafia V: Official game thread (Day 7 - Game Over. Town Win!)

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Edge:

I would only feel comfortable discussing this with a select few because then they'd all be innocent townies, not mixed in with scum.

Whoa, what are you talking about? I hope you're not discussing this game with other players outside this OFFICIAL thread cause that's against the rules. :o

No. What are you talking about? Because I was talking about masons.

Consider this... In the past few hours Edge has said all of this:
1. Edge says he has "Something to say but no one would believe him". We say, say it, we'll believe you. Then he refuses.
2. His posts have almost caused hysteria now! Aeris, and Fran have both made posts saying just how confused they are.
3. He's talking about "Thinking of all possiblitlies." Right now shouldn't our concern be about the mafia thats been downing us one by one every night? He can say he's not trying to distract anyone, but thats like saying no offence after an insult, he's still doing it.

I still have time to analyze, but Edge is pretty high on my suspect list.

Still doing it? I've moved on from the cult discussion because some of you clearly don't want to even fathom it. And I didn't refuse to say anything. I said I would discuss it with people who are confirmed townies. Otherwise, it's a no go. It would make more sense if I revealed my role, but I don't think I want to do that right now. Leave it to the scum to quickly accuse people when they bring up theories. And I don't necessarily believe your role claim as a cop. The only way I would believe it is if you investigated me tonight and then posted the results tomorrow. That is the only way I know you're telling the truth. Though, you could just as easily be making it up then too.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Fran:


Of all the people who are actively posting, "The Ramza" has been the one who has most quick-votes, random-votes, vote hopping, and bandwagoning. Why is it that I'm the only one suspicious of him? Is it cause you guys think that his erratic behavior is due to someone who is simply a poor player? Cause obviously, despite his erratic voting and posting, he's survived this long. And he's just gonna keep on surviving, I bet.

Biggest suspects to me are:

Ramza (even though I feel like the rest of you will keep ignoring Ramza as a potential scum)
Edge (his most recent posts are very weird)
Edgar (I don't know if I buy his cop roleclaim)

People like Cid, Quina, Riona, Aeris I feel like I can't get a good read on.

At this point, I feel like the following people really need to post more:

Vivi
Firion

[[M] Gaius]

Edgar:

Consider this... In the past few hours Edge has said all of this:
1. Edge says he has "Something to say but no one would believe him". We say, say it, we'll believe you. Then he refuses.
2. His posts have almost caused hysteria now! Aeris, and Fran have both made posts saying just how confused they are.
3. He's talking about "Thinking of all possiblitlies." Right now shouldn't our concern be about the mafia thats been downing us one by one every night? He can say he's not trying to distract anyone, but thats like saying no offence after an insult, he's still doing it.

I still have time to analyze, but Edge is pretty high on my suspect list.

Still doing it? I've moved on from the cult discussion because some of you clearly don't want to even fathom it. And I didn't refuse to say anything. I said I would discuss it with people who are confirmed townies. Otherwise, it's a no go. It would make more sense if I revealed my role, but I don't think I want to do that right now. Leave it to the scum to quickly accuse people when they bring up theories. And I don't necessarily believe your role claim as a cop. The only way I would believe it is if you investigated me tonight and then posted the results tomorrow. That is the only way I know you're telling the truth. Though, you could just as easily be making it up then too.

What are you talking about!?!
Talking to only confirmed citizens is against the roles. You can't PM people!
If I was scum, why would I want to shift focus on the mafia? No, if I was scum I'd love everyone to be on the lookout for a crazy cult. If there's a cult the the town has already lost. (That would mean there's probably at least 2-3 mafians and 5 cult members, leaving 2-3 townies left). I refuse to believe there is a cult, because if there is a cult, then I may as well give up, pack up, and go home.
Next, asking for an investigation never proves anything, we still haven't killed a godfather yet.

[[M] Caprica]

Rinoa:


If The Ramza is mafia then Edgar is mafia or Naive Cop. At this point I don't think there is a Naive Cop. Mafia already had a town role that could help them, and that was Saulus.

I really want to know what Edge and Fran's roles are. Almost enough to vote for them. I'm willing to reveal my role if you guys do the same.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Edge:

What are you talking about!?!
Talking to only confirmed citizens is against the roles. You can't PM people!
If I was scum, why would I want to shift focus on the mafia? No, if I was scum I'd love everyone to be on the lookout for a crazy cult. If there's a cult the the town has already lost. (That would mean there's probably at least 2-3 mafians and 5 cult members, leaving 2-3 townies left). I refuse to believe there is a cult, because if there is a cult, then I may as well give up, pack up, and go home.
Next, asking for an investigation never proves anything, we still haven't killed a godfather yet.

Uh again, what are you talking about? I never PM anyone, but myself about this game. Now, you're just making stuff up. The masons would be the confirmed citizens I'd be able to talk to if I were recruited.

[[M] Aaron]

Firion

If The Ramza is mafia then Edgar is mafia or Naive Cop. At this point I don't think there is a Naive Cop. Mafia already had a town role that could help them, and that was Saulus.

Just would like to point out something that people may have overlooked.

but wait, after the shocking scene, Freya found something else nestled in that bush. One of these roles is NOT in play

Beloved Princess
Faith Healer
Mafia Cop

We know that the faith healer is in that means one of them is left. And if you think, he may be telling the truth about all the innocents. A mafia cop may do that. *whistles*

fyi: another reason I haven't been posting is cause I hate when I type things out and they are skimmed over

[[M] Caprica]

Rinoa:


I don't think the Masons can recruit people.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Edge:

I don't think the Masons can recruit people.

Only if there is a recruiting mason role.

[[M] Caprica]

Rinoa:


Chances are, there isn't, or the masons would be directing us right now.

[[M] Gaius]

Edgar:

What are you talking about!?!
Talking to only confirmed citizens is against the roles. You can't PM people!
If I was scum, why would I want to shift focus on the mafia? No, if I was scum I'd love everyone to be on the lookout for a crazy cult. If there's a cult the the town has already lost. (That would mean there's probably at least 2-3 mafians and 5 cult members, leaving 2-3 townies left). I refuse to believe there is a cult, because if there is a cult, then I may as well give up, pack up, and go home.
Next, asking for an investigation never proves anything, we still haven't killed a godfather yet.

Uh again, what are you talking about? I never PM anyone, but myself about this game. Now, you're just making stuff up. The masons would be the confirmed citizens I'd be able to talk to if I were recruited.

You made that very unclear, especially since we don't even know if there is a mason recruiter, but my question is we're on what can be one of the last days, and your hoping on that? Thats weak. I hope if there is a mason recruiter he realizes that would be an easy mafia trick to get him to kill himself.

If The Ramza is mafia then Edgar is mafia or Naive Cop. At this point I don't think there is a Naive Cop. Mafia already had a town role that could help them, and that was Saulus.

Just would like to point out something that people may have overlooked.

but wait, after the shocking scene, Freya found something else nestled in that bush. One of these roles is NOT in play

Beloved Princess
Faith Healer
Mafia Cop

We know that the faith healer is in that means one of them is left. And if you think, he may be telling the truth about all the innocents. A mafia cop may do that. *whistles*
fyi: another reason I haven't been posting is cause I hate when I type things out and they are skimmed over

Technically I can't refute that there could be a mafia cop. So yeah.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Edge:

You made that very unclear, especially since we don't even know if there is a mason recruiter, but my question is we're on what can be one of the last days, and your hoping on that? Thats weak. I hope if there is a mason recruiter he realizes that would be an easy mafia trick to get him to kill himself.

I don't see how that's unclear. Since Cyan was a mason it wouldn't be that far fetched to presume that there is a recruiting mason. Nice to see you keep distracting away from your unconfirmed role claim to focus on something unimportant like this.

[[M] Gaius]

Edgar:


Of course I've moved on from my roleclaim. Because there is, technically no more I can do to prove my claim. I've moved on to trying to figure out what the hell your trying to do here, which I just can't figure out. You acted like you have an important role or something but won't let the town in on it despite it being this late in the game. How am I suppose to trust that?

[[M] Caprica]

Rinoa:


There are ten people left. The following people probably aren't Mason (since they claimed to be other things and I don't think Masons would lie):

Edgar
The Ramza

I will state right now that I am not a Mason. Edge, you apparently aren't a Mason. I also don't think Fran is a Mason. That would leave 5 people left who could be Masons. If there was a recruiting Mason then one would be added each night. Take out Cyan and that leaves 4 Masons. One person left. There is NOT one Mafia left. There is at least a Godfather, and I'm guessing a Prostitute, and/or Mafia Cop. That means someone in our group (you, me, Ramz, Ed, and Fran) is a mafia. I'm not Mafia. For now I believe Edgar and The Ramza are the roles they claim to be. That leaves a short list of people who could be mafia, and you're on it.

I do not think there is a recruiting Mason. There has to be at least one more (unless Psy is a tricky bastard), and at most 3 more. My guess is there are two more.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Edge:


You people are notorious at not believing role claims which is reason number 1 why I don't want to say it. But, I will because I'm tired of the constant discussion about it. I am (SPOILER)the vigilante.

I also didn’t want to say anything because then I’d be an easy target for mafia and I’ve also been a bit of a liability for the townies. Sorry about that. I killed off Basch, Cyan and sort of killed off Barret (it was my other half’s doing). I thought Basch was mafia because he was pretty inactive and only came in to vote every once in a while.

It turns out I was wrong. Again, sorry. This means it wasn’t me who killed off Auron on night 3 and I doubt the mafia would kill off their own, so that’s why I was thinking there might be a third faction, but I could still be wrong about that.

This also means that there probably isn’t a paranoid gun owner, over-eager vigilante, jack of all trades, and anything else that you people have claimed practically every day.

After all of this, I'm still not sure who to vote for. My replacement replacement and I have been trying to decide who to vote for, but could never make up our minds so we just never voted, and when I wanted to vote it was too late. Sorry about that too.

[[M] Aaron]

Firion


Alright kiddos, STOP WORRYING ABOUT MASONS! Tbh why does it matter!? They are pro town! (exclamation points makes it fact! ) There would be too many now anyway.

Ok now look, if I recall correctly, which oh *looks it up* (yes, I do such things, you know.... get evidence, crazy huh!) A mafia cop does the same thing, looks up to find out who is who during the night. A mafia member would know who his team mates are and as you know, this game was smack full of roles. They probably gathered that there were other killing roles. (See Lovers for reference) So of course innocent would be great things to find while looking up. Yes mentioning them isn't so bad either. It clears you from heat such as... now possibly?

Preview edit: Oh rinoa posted what I said, just more throughly.