Mafia: World War three, sign up and questions thread

[Aerith's Knight]

Now nobody can complain.

BULL I can't complain XD Just wait till after mafia ;D

you ruined the game.. and confused the hell out of me because of that.. so no. You cant complain

[edczxcvbnm]

Now nobody can complain.:p

BULL:skull::skull::skull::skull: I can't complain XD Just wait till after mafia ;D

you ruined the game.. and confused the hell out of me because of that.. so no. You cant complain

Have naive you are...you should know that I can ALWAYS complain =D

[Del Murder]

More like do, not can.

[demondude]

It's like his daily regime. xD

[Aerith's Knight]

like breathing for us normal humans xD

[edczxcvbnm]

Exactly XD

[edczxcvbnm]

Now let me complain XD

By letting the town know what is up it let the brother know what is up. For all he knew, there was 3 mafia or 2 mafia left and not 4. Had you not said anything he could have started to vote not knowing what is up with the mafia side. Because of that he could have voted to lynch someone else along with the town and the game could have kept going on with a much different outcome(okay...I admit that this probably was not gonna happen).

Overall, I think you let the town know too much near the end. This is the first game with multiple factions and I am not so sure that revealing the cult is dead until the end of the game is necessary but I see the other argument as well that no one really knows the mafia is dead in a straight up town vs mafia game until mafia is all dead. I don't think the cult being eliminated should have been known. I think it adds a different dynamic to the game about what faction to still go after.

[Shiny]

Hehe, I knew Japan was mafia. I can't believe the town didn't realize that.

[[M] Adama]

How'd you realize? I had such a perfect and air tight allibi. T_T

[Psychotic]

How'd you realize? I had such a perfect and air tight allibi. T_T

On Day Three you stated you had no idea how the vigilante role worked.

[oddler]

Bah. qwerty thinks entirely too much like me.

[Psychotic]

Why did the mafia rape you all so hard? Three reasons.

A) The Cult was not the major force we (and all of you) predicted it to be. If it was, maybe that could've been a way to weaken the mafia. Unfortunately, it wasn't.

B) The town was just plain bad.

Day One:
- Foreplay lynch on Australia/New Zealand. Fair enough. You all decide Germany is the way to go...why? because he switched votes? Uh, guys, why the hell would a scum draw attention to themself like that on day one? Oh it's day one, boo, let's lynch anyone! If that's your attitude, enjoy your loss while the mafia lie low and don't join your bandwagon.
- Canada. Oh hi guys I'm super smart! Serial Killer, Mafia, Cult all target them because of that post. Acting smart on day one (where the idiots rule) is bad enough, but when you're the cop? Madness. Utter madness.

Day Two:
- Most of you guys vote for New Zealand without giving any reason. OK. Well done. That's some good thinking, because I'm sure it helps people when analysing votes when reasons aren't given. And then New Zealand implodes because NeoCracker sucks. Fantastic! So uh...what did you learn from who voted NeoCracker off, guys? Nothing at all? Oh. Great.

Day Three:
Day three was the worst playing in EoFF Mafia history. Yes, even worse than the Disney Mafia, it was that bad.
- Demon Dude, well, what the smurf. Not even going to bother with that. But the way you guys reacted bordered on the retarded. The mafia/cult is a TEAM. Do you really think someone's scum mates would A) Allow them to claim for no reason and B) Claim something that's not even in the game? Seriously? Stop going for the stupid people for the love of god! The mafia led that lynch, and you followed like sheep.

- Your WORST CRIME EVER was speed lynching the guy. You didn't let the likes of Iraq, Mexico and the USA even post because you were so fast. Great thinking, gang! Way to go! How are you supposed to analyse people if you don't even let them post and vote? And here's the kicker: It doesn't even make the game go quicker. The night will always end at the same time - whenever some lousy bastard gets back online. All you did was extend the night time and shorten the day time. Fantastic.

Oh, and maybe if you'd let Iraq post, he could've told you that he investigated Russia the previous night...

And enter the Beloved Princess kill. Game over = Night 3 as far as I'm concerned. From then on you guys picked up, though, and actually discussed things. But you were already doomed to be honest.

Vigilante deserves a special mention.

One mafia killed gains you a day - cancels out the Beloved Princess effect. Regardless, they wasted two days and nights with false kills. And why? Italy? What did Italy do? As far as I know, the UK was killed purely 'cause Roto was going on about it in the discussion thread. Here's a tip: Don't take advice from someone who was lynched on day one. China was suspicious because the people controlling it couldn't get to their computer a lot and had password issues and therefore rarely posted? Come on, guys. Come the hell on. Brazil was kinda dodgy though! Regardless, we made it clear to the vigilantes that they didn't have to kill people, that bad things would happen if they did, and they still went and did it anyway.

On the subject, Japan's vig claim. Japan stated on day three that he had NO IDEA HOW THE VIGILANTE ROLE WORKED! Bit of an obvious giveaway that he was bullting if you ask me...

Also, hunting for the cult? Why? You thought there were lots of them? Two things that should've tipped you off. The mafia were smurfing obsessed with finding the cult in the thread. Seriously, look over Japan's posts for example. All the dude ever did was talk about the cult non-stop. If everyone's talking about the cult...do the math, they're not in control, the mafia are. Again, they led, you followed. Also, no cultists were being killed. Doesn't that strike you as odd?

C) The mafia were pretty damn good! Well done guys.

[edczxcvbnm]

The town this time was pretty piss poor all around.

Fail role claims
Rouge Vigilante
Couldn't spot stuff like Japan claiming he is something he didn't know

I can't believe you didn't go after the brothers O_o Seriously...it is a kill on the mafia and the brother could betray you eventually(and did). Either way you have to do it eventually to win.

[Aerith's Knight]

I r awsome ^^

first time in the mafia and a win!

[qwertysaur]

I r awsome ^^

first time in the mafia and a win!

Sure thing North Korea