I think it's really down to 1, 3, or 5

I'm gonna post my opinion on the 3 the more I looked

Candidate 1
The thing that gets me about the candidate the more I look at them, is they're is nothing really weak, but nothing really strong about them either. They're pretty much moderate in every aspect, except for how long they've been here.
the negative/positive was sorta combined here

Candidate 3
negative
Not participating in forum events seems to be everyone's gripe with this guy. Sure, I can see that, but again, how many people here always participate in them? Also says much less so active, in the general areas.
positive
He's extremely active in the gaming areas. Being much less active in the general might still be normal person active. If the average is say 500, and this guy posts 1,000 in gaming, but posts 400 in general, that's much less active, but still active. On top of that, he is well respected, and gives out advice. Someone you can look up to

Candidate 5
Alright, the more I look at this guy, the more I see his role in this forum. This guy is always coming up with new events. He also shy's away from confrontation. I say let this guy do exactly what he's good at. Let him come up with the cool events for the site to do. Making this person an admin could cut back majorly into this, and end up hurting the site more than helping.

THE JACKEL