Alright, after talking to The JACKAL and looking over the candidates more I think that 1 and 3 have a lot of potential, I also think 5 is a good candidate, but I am looking at 1 and 3 because they are active in opposite areas.

As we are looking for someone to join our staff we should look at where we are most active in so we can see where we need to beef up our activity, if we are mostly active in the General Areas of the forum than that makes 3 look like a stronger applicant, if we are strong everywhere than that makes 1 look more useful because as oddler said he has a smart unique personality and outlook that not many others have. That is something that could be invaluable in a staff.

Thank you oddler for pointing that out.