... Is no one even listing to my suggestions?

Viewing the entire forum isn’t a huge deal if we have two people that focus on two different aspects of the site, and still look at the rest of the site. 1 and 3 BOTH look at the whole site, they just have an area they focus on, so they have an area they could focus there moderating abilities on.

Now I am not hell bent on keeping 5 out of the staff by any means, I just think we should hold off on promoting him. And if you two keep arguing like this then we are not going to come to our decision in time! Neither of you are going to change your views so how about you look at the other aspects that could make someone a good CK?