OK then guys, before we start jumping in to analysing people, perhaps it would be best if we decide on some kind of a universal rating system we can all use to grade the candidates as we see fit, perhaps coming to some amiable conclusion based on that. We can still use this thread to discuss more thoroughly which of the above candidates we would choose.
I suggest we use the following criteria;
- History ; Has the user ever been in trouble? Have they exceeded in some way?
- Activity ; How often are they on? Do they post often?
- Personality ; Is the person suitable material? Are they mature?
- Community Spirit ; Are they liked much within the community? Will they interact well with other members as a CK?
