I vote for Candidate 5, for a couple of reasons.
A) They are well liked by the entire community, not just the noobs or oldbies.
B) They've already tried to make the forum a better place by making new events.
And along with their good points, they have their bad points too.
A) Shy and non-confrontational, so they might leave any of the face to face moderation to others.
B) Sporadic activity.
This candidate's pros out weigh their cons, though. So I think 5 would make a good CK.
