Mafia IX: Ace Edition Game Over - Mafia Victory - Town of Failure Destroyed

[[M] Apollo]

What? Why would you encourage him to roleclaim? Unless its something like "Bulletproof" that could just put a bullet in Jean's forehead.

I'm not going to chalk up Luke as "just being a newbie." The first time I played I was mafia and I used that excuse to get out of more then one sticky situation. I believe when someone is making scummy moves chalking it up to newbieness a mistake.

[[M] Athena]

LET'S DO THIS THANG.

On Godot:
Confirmed Insane Cop says the guy is innocent, you've just got to go with it, you've just got to, or else what the hell is the point in having cops if you're just going to ignore them? Yes, okay, we now know Demon Dude was being an unfunny heel and I think that's tipped what would have been a balanced game heavily into the mafia's favour.

From the good to the bad. There will be no Damon Gant and Klavier Gavin. Why? I want to see how certain events play out first.

Jean Armstrong:
Oh my lord he's smart he's smart he's smart he's smart. For the love of holy tits, townsfolk, stop this please. Say something original about me.

Plum and Furio Tiger.
I think they are town. I think they are nervous players who I think should play with more confidence and look for avenues of their own and express them, but they're not scum.

Franziska von Karma
Bit of spaghetti plating but they seem town to me.


Dick Gumshoe
Couple of things that have made me go "Hmm what" but yeah the dude seems town.

Emma Skye
Bit dodgy on the first day, posting more townish as the game goes on, no real problems here.

Wesley Stickler
That roleclaim out of nowhere is still pretty wtf for me. Perhaps it's a scum overeager to share a pre-prepared claim. But besides that, I think they're alright.

Bikini
I don't know what the smurf because of inactives. You could argue that because mafia is a good role and she had to be replaced, she might not be scum.

Valant
Replacement logic? maybe, but Valant's "These people voted off the doctor and this forms the sole basis of my list of suspects" is scummy as hell though

Luke Atmey
A bit of chain lynching but as I read his posts, I couldn't see an ulterior motive behind any of it, so yeah. Townish, but someone to keep an eye on just in case.

Maya Fey
Seems to spend a lot of their time complaining about work and the amount of spam than actually posting about mafia! I really was not keen on the idea of lynching Luke to prove my own status.

Will Powers
Incredibly wishy washy. Like, to the max. Was straight on the Hotti claim on Day One (presumably if he is scum he'd know that Hotti was full of ) but then changed his mind and went with Mia. Day 2, I asked people to withold on Hotti for a bit and he did, but then later he goes right back onto Hotti again. Day 3, shifts between Godot and Plum. Seems too eager to go along with public opinion.

THE DODGY QUARTET!
Consists of Phoenix Wright, Apollo Justice, Trucy Wright and Miles Edgeworth.

To me all four have been keeping their heads down, making few posts and hardly showing a stance on most issues. Middle of the road, non-controversial stuff, and don't seem to want to make any waves. Phoenix Wright hasn't been around a lot, Trucy has been playing up the newbie angle. They often talk about sifting through the thread as an excuse to low activity (and hey I admit I just talked about that in my previous post but I came out and addressed some issues first rather than using it to stay out of sight) Miles is the worst of the four for all of this though, I feel. I really did not like his vote for Phoenix Wright for inactivity yesterday - he'd been bigging up Godot as the great Satan all day long but when it came down to Godot v Plum, he wussed out and went for Phoenix Wright out of the blue.

Larimoir
I 100% agree that Larimoir is extremely scummy. I might be repeating some of the stuff Franziska said but I read the thread in order so this is stuff I've been compiling.

On Day 1 she sat back, then popped in out of nowhere onto Mia after Godot and Gavin (both confirmed town which is important - mafia will not be voting in blocks, they will see what the townies do) do first.

Makes some bland contributions like

Here's a thought, why did the mafia kill Kristoph Gavin?"

Franziska says it was to lead us down the wrong path; I disagree. It's to make it look like she's contributing but not. Seriously, I know who you are, Lammy Love - the act never works for long. I know you know like that doesn't help anyone. General non-controversial statement that you think nobody will bother even reading or answering.

And despite being inactive and keeping her head down, look who pops up as soon as she is called out properly. Ha.

[[M] Athena]

I do believe I was their target yes, for reasons that shall not be revealed.

Told you jackasses not to target me.

These reasons are moving you up on my list you were 3, now your 2. explain nows or face my vote change abilities.

Oh okay, I'm down for some bestiality. I'll make your tiger tiger burn bright before this night is through.

So, these reasons? Here you go.

HEY MAFIA!!!!

WANT TO KNOW MY ROLE????

I THINK I WILL ANNOUNCE IT TO THE ENTIRE TOWN SO THAT YOU WILL KNOW WHAT YOU ARE UP AGAINST!!!!

I agree with Tigre. Jean, if you are ever gonna hide something from everyone, don't say you are. It makes you look bad.

So you want me to hide the fact that I am hiding something? :rolleyes2 And I don't care if it makes me look bad - if that's what it takes for me to tell the town I think it was me they were after, so be it.

Not explaining why I think it was me because it's to do with roles and if you guys don't like that, tough . I'm not revealing it until I'm on the verge of being lynched.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

I believe thats good enough to make me not care anymore you are near the bottom of my list good job

[[M] Athena]

Hi-five, bud.

[[M] Elize]

Considering that Jean was bottom of my suspect list already that speech has done nothing but make me want to hump his leg

[[M] Colette]

To all the people who asked me why I said my previous post when no one suspected me. Well, the person above that post did, based on previous actions.

Then everyone starts talking about the death of Kristoph and that's exactly what my post would be about. I have no idea what happened there, I don't know why I would be held responsible and have absolutely no way to defend myself against that. Seems kind of unfair to hold that against me tbh. But do as you will, I will just keep playing.

gimme a sec to read up.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

Considering that Jean was bottom of my suspect list already that speech has done nothing but make me want to hump his leg

I'd do that even when I suspected him

[[M] Elize]

I'll have sex with him even if he turns out to be scum

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

too late I beat you to it

[[M] Apollo]

I'm sorry but I can't ignore this.

Considering that Jean was bottom of my suspect list already that speech has done nothing but make me want to hump his leg

Jean Armstong: He's too smart for my liking. Granted he might be trying to unite the town, but mostly it seems he's trying to turn us against each other. He may be a sexy manbeast, but he's definitely got some kind of power role. Mafia or not I don't know yet.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Regarding Phoenix Wright: He said that he'd be busy for a couple of days but he'd try to pop in at least once a day to take part. He hasn't. >_>

[[M] Kurt - Cool Dad]

Why wait till now to make that post Jeany? :laugh:

[[M] Athena]

I don't know why I would be held responsible and have absolutely no way to defend myself against that. Seems kind of unfair to hold that against me tbh.

Nah, it's perfectly fair to hold it against you if the guy you replaced acted scummy, sweet meat. It's a tough break, I'll give you that, but you agreed to be a replacement and knew what you were getting yourself into.

You can't just expect us to ignore the last three days of Damon Gant and work by what you've done since replacing him because then we'd have nothing whatsoever to go on.

Why wait till now to make that post Jeany? :laugh:

I think it takes three days to get a full grasp of what everyone's all about really. When Day 4 started it was my bedtime, and since I got online today I've been reading the entire thread, making notes and typing up that thing. My notes still aren't even complete yet.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

I'm sorry but I can't ignore this.

Considering that Jean was bottom of my suspect list already that speech has done nothing but make me want to hump his leg

Jean Armstong: He's too smart for my liking. Granted he might be trying to unite the town, but mostly it seems he's trying to turn us against each other. He may be a sexy manbeast, but he's definitely got some kind of power role. Mafia or not I don't know yet.

Muy bien Dicky nice catch care to explain luke