Quote Originally Posted by Bikini
And the last cop NEVER investigated anyone.
Yes. Assume he investigated no-one because it's irrelevant to all of this.

Last night there was no kill, when the night before there were two. I thought something involving my own role (revealing it will not resolve this situation fyi) might have caused this. Apparently others beg to differ.

What must the mafia have thought? Perhaps they, having read my post, did indeed target me and thought it was something to do with my role as I did. Thus lessening the chances of the existance of a roleblocker? Possibly. But still.

If Will is mafia, he is the godfather. To me, Lamimoir's (CAN'T SPELL) claim that he is innocent isn't anything. We relied too heavily on cops before and we got burned for it hard. I've always hated a reliance on them when things can often go wrong with millers, godfathers, sanity, etc. and you can figure things out for yourself if you want to.

And so, as Bikini puts it
Why would such a powerful Mafia role stick his neck out like this, when there really isn't a need?
Indeed. Notice that he hints at it long before claiming.
Quote Originally Posted by Will
to karma- I have a small idea of what happened. I think the roleblocker got the right person and we either have some bulletproofs or we have more protective roles.
Italicised for relevance.

Why would a Godfather stick himself out just to get a townie lynched? He wouldn't; Plum is not popular with the town anyway after the debacle of yesterday. Based on this, if he is scum, assume Plum is too and he is distancing. But-

Will has been on Plum since Day 2. Admittedly he's been a bit wishy washy between Plum and others, but as things were going well for the mafia, I don't know why he'd be all over Plum's case if they were on the same team so early.

And why not claim something more powerful which will give him more credibility when Plum dies? In fact, Roleblocker is a role with a margin for error. You can say it was just coincidence that there were no night kills and that Plum was mafia. You can't with cop/tracker. Yeah evidently with one cop it's hard, but tracker is feasible I think.

Will claims after a couple of us found him to be a bit odd. Interesting enough I guess, trying to save himself as the important role of godfather and regain credibility?

The purple/green thing is dodgy! It makes his claim - which, if he is telling the truth, should never have been made in the first place because of how inconclusive it all is - less valid and less believable.

And so Emma. If Emma is scum, why lie about being a roleblocker? You're sacrificing yourself just to get a roleblocker killed? This makes less sense to me than any situation invovling Will wanting Emma lynched.

There cannot be two roleblockers, can there? Will's claim does not seem genuine, but he does not seem to be acting like a mafia - Lamiroir's cop claim backs him up. Emma has no reason for acting this way either. So-

THEORY AND WHERE YOU WILL WANT TO BE IF TL;DR!
Is Will a lyncher and Plum a lynchee? It explains his innocence in the cop investigation. It explains why he has been all over Plum's case. It explains why he would lie about being a roleblocker - which I think he could well be - to get her lynched.

if so we're absolutely smurfed 'cause we've had two power roles claim for nothing.