Mafia IX: Ace Edition Game Over - Mafia Victory - Town of Failure Destroyed

[[M] Colette]

Now is the time for hard descisions for me. Town can't afford another townie kill and if I pick the wrong person(Ema or Will) I will be next. That would mean that another 2 townies would die, plus the 4 that die in the night. God! Pressure!

Let's hear their responses first.

[[M] Apollo]

@Gant: How do you know there are two mafian factions? And if it was a 50/50 percentages of Mafians to Townies we'd have lost already.

[[M] Colette]

There are two kills at night aren't there?

Plus, In large games they usually put 2 4-team mafia's.

No, I mean that with Vanilla's usually staying inactive, because that's boring, and Mafia's being active, seeing as they want to steer people away from mafia members, the percentage that actually posts would be 50/50, definitely now that 3 active townie posters died.

[[M] Helo]

There are two kills at night aren't there?

Plus, In large games they usually put 2 4-team mafia's.

No, I mean that with Vanilla's usually staying inactive, because that's boring, and Mafia's being active, seeing as they want to steer people away from mafia members, the percentage that actually posts would be 50/50, definitely now that 3 active townie posters died.

What usually happens should not be conclusive evidence of what happens in this game. All Mafia games I've seen have been unique. The mods can really do whatever the hell they want.

Vanilla Townies had better not be inactive, now more than ever. Yeah, we've lost a lot of power roles, but there's still a (though admittedly small) chance we can pull this out with our collective mindset. If we could only figure out who was Mafia.

Also, Gant, this post makes me more suspicious of you. You've been fairly active of late, and now you're saying that Mafia will be more active than Town? Come on, man! Are you telling us you're Mafia? I have no idea. But I don't like the sound of your post.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Okay, I've read through everything again and thought things over, and I'm going to vote Ema instead.

##Unvote: Will Powers
##Vote: Ema Skye


I don't think there's a second mafia Gant. We most likely have a bad vigilante or a serial killer. Maaaybe Lovers with a gun.

[[M] Kurt - Cool Dad]

You're wrong Miles. Towns = green. Even special roles like doctor and cop that have usually been colors like yellow and aqua respectively were announced as green. So why would role blocker be any different?

And also, I find it funny how Jean was killed last night. The same day that he called you out and voted for you.

EDIT: @ Gant: Like I said, highly doubt there are two factions now since it would be too unbalanced. Why are you so sure that there is two factions?

Furio, Plum and tracy what do you think of this?

[[M] Helo]

Good point, Valant. Though I don't think that should be conclusive evidence that Miles is completely guilty, though we should indeed put a watch on him. Jean had many other reasons to be a target. He was obviously Psychotic, a renowned Mafia player, and he hinted numerous times to having a power role. Two dangerous things for a Mafia to have to deal with, I'd wager. Someone got rid of him probably for those reasons.

Then again, this brings up the possibility that Miles could have a separate killing role, and was a vengeful man. Who knows? It's worth speculating about.

[[M] Helo]

PS: Judge, votecount?

[[M] Apollo]

Gant youve just made my suspect list, but I'm still for voting Plum or Ema out of evidence and inactivity.

[[M] Colette]

@Wesley: Ive been active because Ive been replaced. How could you not have noticed that discussion?

@valant: Because It's a 24-player game. The last.. 4 games(?) that had 24 players had 2 factions. It is possible that they used one big mafia, but why would they? If it is, we are certainly screwed. Because that means all night kills are synchronised. Im not saying it is so, Im saying it is most likely.

@Dick: g4u.


Btw vigilante? Jessweee isnt Vigilante again, right? xD

Would explain a lot. xD XD

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

Gant is either a very disorganized player who's new, or scum trying to mess us up. There's no evidence of a second mafia, let alone that they have 4 members. It's possible, but we can't jump to conclusions with no proof. If it were true then town should just quit now because we still had trouble winning the last game and we got 1 mafia kill every day.

You're wrong Miles. Towns = green. Even special roles like doctor and cop that have usually been colors like yellow and aqua respectively were announced as green. So why would role blocker be any different?

@#&$&#^@ With the stupid color argument already! Besides where did I state Judge didn't announce it to people in other colors? I've never denyed that it was in green for town. If you read my post I was stating that basing the fact that people are adding color to their roles based on the past games use of them is a TERRIBLE indication of scumminess.

However since you see to not want to let off this and seem to want to use idiotic evidence on people to determine scum, I'm nearly inclined to say you are scum just for the fact that your using terrible evidence and trying to make me out as a bad guy by spreading misinformation.

And also, I find it funny how Jean was killed last night. The same day that he called you out and voted for you.

Yes. Jean was obviously killed by me because I'm a dumb mafia who kills people that are already huge threats to start, but only do so after he calls me out. Yeah I'm totally that dumb dude....seriously haven't I already talked about this in a previous post about another person and set ups? I swear to god I did.

[[M] Kurt - Cool Dad]

It is not terrible evidence. Jean had a similar revelation and surprisingly I agree with it. Though of course, as soon as I say something mildly intellectual here you people go with your stupid "no that's dumb evidence". Stfu. No evidence is dumb evidence. If I want to actually contribute stuff instead of the mindless stuff some people have been posting in this thread, then let me. I am not saying you have to agree but to keep arguing with me about it is not going to change my mind and only makes you seem much more scummier. You're wrong. End of story.

[[M] Kurt - Cool Dad]

@ Gant: Well there's 16 players. If there were two factions that would mean it would have to be split evenly most likely. Usually there's like 4-6 mafia. If there's two mafia factions with members of four then we're basically screwed because then that means if a townie dies today we lose. I think this is highly unlikely and that there seems to be a vig/serial killer. And I don't know why you seem to think there are two. Stop tying to scare people.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

Your arguing....COLOR! Your basing COLOR as evidence to lynch someone. I can't even begin to fathom how that could be a good idea.

No evidence is dumb evidence.

Well apparently there is or else we wouldn't be having this argument.

As far as I can see your entire argument against me is "Jean said it!" and "ZOMG Color isn't a good reason to call someone scum?" Sorry your argument against me is failed and weak at best.

The only wrong one I see here is you. You've just shot up my suspect list.

[[M] Kurt - Cool Dad]

Hm, let's see if my argument is wrong. I am curious now. If I am wrong then I will retract my color comment and apologize. If I am not wrong and you are dumb then your irl persona must lick my knees. Deal? Kthanx.

##Vote: Will Powers