Well, unless the newcomer for Gant can somehow defend himself from previous actions he didn't do, I'm voting for him.

Gant has been extremely suspicious up until now, and yet there is now way he can defend himself from any actions that I can think of.

This leads me to vote for him, which I admit is not fair to the newcomer, but I am way to nervous to allow something that can't be defended to just slip on by me.