Mafia X: Harry Potter and the LYNCHER WINS HURRAY! oh and town beat mafia I s'pose

[[M] D'Anna]

WELL the more I read the more I think this is bad situation... Ron didn't even vote for Crabbe. He made it sound like he does have a role that could be insane (doesn't mean cop! There's more than one role that could be insane and prolly made up ones too with this game's craziness)... well either that or he's using it as a cover up... but it's a lot of a coincidence for Crabbe to say Ron is insane then, isn't it?

I'm not trying to defend Crabbe but this doesn't seem right...

[[M] Elize]

One of the main reason I didn't unvote at the beginning when he roleclaimed. Let's say he is a shrink, and let's say Ron is insane. What is the chance that the first time Crabbe investigates someone, he/she turns out to be insane.

It would just be... Insane! xD

[[M] Aaron]

None of this seems right, Tonks speak up a bit more I want to hear your opinions, you have been quiet and I think some gentle investigation always helps.

[[M] D'Anna]

I have not been quiet, you've been quiet. You speak up!

[[M] Aaron]

I just want day 1 to end!

##vote: Ron

[[M] Ron - Cop Dad]

I believe an important part of mafia is the deception of pro-town being good.
They can be out for their own gain, and I don't trust doctors who protect themselves in the hope they will survive to the end, it is selfish and thus the credibility of their role is brought to zero.
Be a team player or I.will.get.you

I'm confused. Correct me if I am wrong, and I'm not going to jump to any conclusions which is why I am asking, but are you saying you will get the doctor unless they are a team player? this does not make any sense to me.

I would be putting a vote on for Crabbe but as others have said, there is no need to rush things along. I can see how his claim might be beliveable, but the way he has gone about it has been a bit silly and I think it is his own fault that things turned out this way.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

One of the main reason I didn't unvote at the beginning when he roleclaimed. Let's say he is a shrink, and let's say Ron is insane. What is the chance that the first time Crabbe investigates someone, he/she turns out to be insane.

It would just be... Insane! xD

That would be and approximate 1 in 21 Chance (assuming Ron is the only insane) since he can't check himself, or Bellatrix because she was dead.

The percent chance of that would be 4.7% Now this chance rises by 4.7% for each insane role. Assuming we have 3 insane roles (seems like a good number) this gives him a 14.1% chance of finding someone who is insane Night 1.

Another thing about this roleclaim other then percent chance, which isn't TOO awful, I mean, its actually better then a 1 in 10 shot, is that its very ambiguous.

Think about it.
"My role tells me if he's insane or not. But I don't know what insane means. I don't know if insane people are in the mafia. I don't know if insane people are pro-town. I don't know what to do once I find an insane person. No one else can figure out if they're insane."

Seems like a role that can make a lot of mistakes without punishment from the town to me

[[M] Aaron]

@ Neville

Only if the doctor is not helping us at all, and is only protecting himself.

Capitilate On Pretentious people.

[[M] D'Anna]

I just want day 1 to end!

##vote: Ron

This is day 2... xD

I s'pose this result will be interesting to wait and see. BBL 'tho.

[[M] Aaron]

Oh .. what happened day 1?

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

I just want day 1 to end!

##vote: Ron

We're in day 2 here

Tonks, Hagrid, Ron, why have you all been so quiet?

[[M] Aaron]

Okay I've just read the thread over and seen the whole Sirius Black killing thing.
ROLECLAIM! LISTEN UP CAREFULLY!

I am an cop I was online during the night period and investigated myself, I came up innocent but there is a reason I role claimed so early.

I will die very soon, I don't know when exactly but I estimate in 3-4 days, the chance of me surviving the the end is zero, I cannot win.

I will investigate Sirius Black tonight and be back in the morning with the result, don't worry about me getting night killed it won't happen, unless a non- scum killing role targets me.

Fire your questions away, I'm prepared to answer them.

P.S I'm an ordinary cop with an unfortunate twist.

[[M] D'Anna]

I have not been quiet! I'm posting ALL THE TIME. I have Sleep and Life Outside Internet too. I shouldn't be here right now. I've talked as much or more than anyone accusing me of being quiet, you twats. But Hagrid has just been staying low and Ron is oddly quiet today 'tho.

[[M] D'Anna]

Wtf...

[[M] D'Anna]

Double wtf...

I saw you edit your post Myrtle. First you claimed insane cop.

##Unvote
##Vote Myrtle

Explain now!