Quote Originally Posted by [M] Ron Weasley View Post
Quote Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid View Post
Quote Originally Posted by [M] Ron Weasley View Post
I agree on the bolded part fully after thinking about the situation Sirius is in. If you all don't agree, then think about this. Cop investigates him only if (s)he feels that Sirius needs investigating. If Sirius comes up guilty, then the cop can announce it, if Sirius is innocent, the cop doesn't announce it. OK?
Why would we want the cop to announce himself this early?

Also, I don't know what to make of Sirius. If he's telling the truth, who was the mafia hit? It just doesn't seem to make sense unless the mafia didn't bother to kill anyone last night (and the godfather was killed by a third killing faction).
Nonono. My plan is simple. We leave Sirius today. Tonight cop investigates him. If cop finds Sirius guilty, (s)he announces it and we lynch him. If cop finds him innocent, (s)he keeps quiet until (s)he finds an actual mafia person for us to kill.
If the cop were smart, (s)he wouldn't reveal themself so soon though, because they would immediately become a prime target for the mafia. Same with the doctor(s). It's just too dangerous.

I think the cop should investigate whoever they find most suspicious right now, until we all have a clear cut suspect that we all agree on.