Mafia X: Harry Potter and the LYNCHER WINS HURRAY! oh and town beat mafia I s'pose

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

At the moment, I'm torn between Sirius and Crabbe. I believe Sirius should have gone for one of the people who jumped to save her. Then we would have got rid of Ginny today, because we would have thought she was Mafia. Which would have been bad, but if he had have killed a Townie, people would have thought Ginny was good, which she was.
I'll get to Crabbe later.

As far as I was concerned, Ginny herself told us far more about the people who tried to save her. If Ginny flips town then we knew Voldy and Hermione aren't panicking scum, but if Voldy or Hermione flipped town then we don't learn anything about the other or Ginny.

c)Thirdly, you used the fact that Sirius has an unusual role to thus legitimize your unusual role. Not bad in and of itself, but we (and by we, I mean I) still don't believe Sirius 100%. (Also sort of an uninteresting role if it's just as he describes it.)

Ha! I agree, I woulda preferred Vanilla

Sirius, you're still on MY list even though killing Ginny would have been a stupid mafia move. At the same time, in your situation, I don't think I would have swung that way either.

I don't quite understand what you mean, if you clarify I could try and explain my thinking.

OH! And I didn't like how Tonks came out so quickly to support Crabbe. I think there's a very high possibility that they're either both scum, or she knows he's not so that she can clear her name by clearing his. Once again, a bit of a stretch, but I'm looking for things to go on.

I missed that. I'm going to go back and read through Tonks' posts now.