Quote Originally Posted by [M] Hermione Granger View Post
At the same time, we don't need an insane cop wandering around, but that will do much less harm than other roles for the time being.
Wait, why wouldn't we want an insane cop? Once they figure out to flip their results, an insane cop is an asset, especially if Crabbe was telling the truth and the insane cop now knows he's insane. Why would we want to get rid of any sort of cop just because he may be wrong or confused at first?

I am, however, still unsure about Crabbe.

If Crabbe isn't scum, why would he want to reveal an insane person publicly? if the person he points out isn't mafia, that means the mafia now knows who an insane cop/doctor is, and that insane cop/doctor ALSO knows, which instantly makes that person a threat to the mafia and a prime target. Goodbye, potential help. And if that insane person IS mafia, the entire mafia now know and can use that person more effectively.

Then again, if Crabbe is scum, I don't see his mafia buddies letting him push himself into the spotlight like that.

Or, he was just lying. That would lead me to think he is scum or a neutral/individual role, trying to get attention drawn to himself.