Have we completely ruled out a second Mafia? You all speak as if that is no longer a possibility. There is a chance, however slim, that Snape's roleclaim is true. The main question is, how do we figure out how to test it? Dudley claims that he is Vanilla Town, but Snape says his role is Godfather. In my opinion, and I might be wrong, the best way to figure it out would be to go after Dudley... If he is a Vanilla Townie, then at least we did not lose a power role, yes? If he is actually a Godfather, then we have just found a very good role to have on our side.

This makes the most sense to me... Dudley claims Vanilla Townie... but, of course, there is a slight possibility that he is just using that as a cover for a power role.

Of course it is all up to the town on what to do.