Knowing someone's specific role is far more powerful than a simple scum/not scum. First of all cops don't even know their sanity, and as we have seen that comes into play a lot.

Knowing someone's specific role is by far the most powerful thing a person can be given. Randomness does not really change it all that much in my opinion. That is why I think there's something strange going on here (well, I know there is).

I'm lost on what to do at this point. We can lynch Snape to see the truth if y'all want.