Have you ever played a game you didn't care for and later tried to give it another chance only to find you it hate even more than you did the first time around?
I finished FFX for the third time and I can honestly say I learn to hate this game more and more each time I play it. I even started laughing during the end parts of the game cause it got so damn cheesy.
The only other title I can think of off the top of my head was Tekken in which every new attempt at playing the series has left me wondering why people think its so damn great.