I did a blue-black once. It didn't have a very blue sheen though. But I have learned something about dying your skin over the years. Its probably too late now, but had you used a facial astringent right afterwards its deep skin cleaning action would have pulled the dye right out. Might still work. But I doubt it

I always keep neutrogena on hand though. But I also always use vasoline or something around my hair line and on my ears to avoid such accidents xD