Saying you don't judge people on how they look (I'm presuming you don't since you've had the audacity to be critical towards my way of approaching it) is probably more arrogant than saying you do.
Agreed. To judge appearance is an automatic human trait. Which is why certain females are more attractive to men than others. For as much as people want to pretend like appearances don't matter, they always will. And in most cases people will ignore this.