Please recommend rpg with a class system.

[ShunNakamura]

Fool,I don't simply say to myself-"Look how popular this game is, I'll buy it cause everyone else does!". Personally I prefer console style rpgs. Nippon Ichi Software, or NIS in America is one of my favorite companies as a matter of fact.

Does it occur perhaps that they are popular for a reason?

Yes, of course but its not a reason of my interest. I'd stick with something thats tried and true, for me thats a JPRG.

Okay, have fun not experiencing some of the greatest games ever made.

I will, because their not, thats an OPINION which I don't share. The greatest games ever made are Final Fantasy VII and Star Ocean 2 imo.

Both fantastic games that I love. But if you are seriously charging that Fallout is anything less than purified genius on a disc, you're simply, and objectively, wrong. I'm not kidding. You are demonstrably incorrect. Your opinion is null and void. You don't have to like it, but you can't deny the quality of the game. I don't like Metroid, but I can't deny that it's incredibly well made, solid, and generally awesome. It's just not to my taste, which is a far cry from the game being bad.

I will have to argue this. A games quality is highly dependent on the enjoyment garnered from the game. Games are entertainment. If they fail to entertain they have failed the objective. No matter how well made the game mechanics are.

Of course having solid game mechanics, a strong story, etc will certainly not hurt a game. However, they alone won't make a good game. A game is supposed to be entertaining.

Therefore some games can be of great quality to some and little quality to others. If you are talking about the quality of individual game elements that is when you can run into objective merits. Such as the mechanics, the story, etc.

For example, I find Fate/Stay Night to be a great game. But others will find it awful. I could argue the game's greatness based on its story, however, if the person I am speaking with can't enjoy the game, the game is awful(from their perspective) no matter how great I can prove the story/mechanics to be.

But in the end of the day games are entertainment, if they aren't entertaining their quality isn't all that high. At least not for that particular person.