No, I am fairly certian I am right.
What are games played for? For most people games are played for entertainment. Thus, as far as that individual is concerned a game that fails to entertain isn't a good game. For another person that same game may entertain making it, at least from their persepctive, a good game.
Once again once you start breaking a game down into its core components and began discussing the quality of the games components then you run into stuff that can be more than subjective.