EoFF Clue - Round Four Day One results are up

[Flying Mullet]

This will be a fun logic game that anyone can join in on at any time. For those of you that aren't familiar with Clue, after a murder you have a list of people, places and weapons and you have to figure out the unique combination of the three to see whodunit, where and with what. We'll be using a similar format here. People can guess one combination of the available items. I'll periodically post, most likely once a day or so, but we'll call it a game day, what each person's guess is and how many parts of the combination are correct, but not which ones. The first one to guess the correct combination wins that round and it's on to another one.

Let me give a quick example:
Weapons: Knife, Gun, Club
Suspects: Man, Woman
Locations: Bathroom, Bedroom
Actual Combination: Club, Woman, Bathroom (She did the dude in on the pooper because women are evil like that)

Game day one guesses:
<b>##Guess</b> Knife, Man, Bathroom
<b>##Guess</b> Gun, Man, Bathroom
<b>##Guess</b> Club, Woman, Bedroom
<b>##Guess</b> Gun, Woman, Bedroom

Game day one responses:
Person 1: Knife, Man, Bathroom (1 correct)
Person 2: Gun, Man, Bathroom (1 correct)
Person 3: Club, Woman, Bedroom (2 correct)
Person 4: Gun, Woman, Bedroom (1 correct)

As it's now game day two, the people playing can either choose dumb luck or apply some logic problem skills to the responses to try and determine what is or isn't part of the combination and submit their game day two guess.

Rules:

• Mark your guesses as <b>##Guess</b> (Mafia-style)
• I'll only accept your first guess and if your guest post is modified I won't accept it (so people don't modify it later on if someone else figures it out in a later post)

That's about it. We'll do a simple one to start off with and see how it goes. Good luck!



<b><i>Round 1</i></b>
<b>Suspects</b>: Fighter, Red Mage, White Mage, Black Mage
<b>Weapons</b>: Club, Axe, Sword, Mace
<b>Location</b>: Earth Cave, Gurgu Volcano, Sea Shrine, Sky Castle

[Rantz]

##Guess: Fighter, Sword, Earth Cave.

[Aerith's Knight]

##Guess: White mage, mace, grudgy vulcano

[Bunny]

##Guess: Black Mage, Axe, Sea Shrine

[Psychotic]

I CALL MISS SCARLET.

Foiled again, rubah.

##Guess: Red Mage, Club, Sky Castle.

[Levian]

##Guess: Black Mage, Mace, Sea Shrine

[Sergeant Hartman]

Colonel Mustard, in the bathroom, with the dildo.

[Loony BoB]

Iiiiiiinteresting. *waits for clues*

[Momiji]

##Guess: White Mage, axe, Sky Castle.

[Loony BoB]

Wait. Do you mean you'll only accept our first guess per day? I'm confused. I thought you meant you'd only accept our first guess at all. But if it's guesses per day, then you can count this:

Suspects: Fighter, Red Mage, White Mage, Black Mage
Weapons: Club, Axe, Sword, Mace
Location: Earth Cave, Gurgu Volcano, Sea Shrine, Sky Castle

##Guess Fighter, Sword, Gurgu Volcano.

[Mittopotahis]

##Guess Red Mage, Mace, Sea Shrine.

[Flying Mullet]

Wait. Do you mean you'll only accept our first guess per day? I'm confused. I thought you meant you'd only accept our first guess at all.

You get one guess between when I reveal how many correct parts there are in each person's guess.

Basically everyone guesses, I reveal the count of correct parts in each guess(unless someone nails it) and then everyone guesses again, etc...

I put that rule in because I didn't want someone making a guess, then two hours later someone posts the correct combination, the first person realizes that, then edits their post and steals the second person's glory.

Does that make sense? Maybe it's an unnecessary rule...

[Loony BoB]

Nono, it's cool. I just got the original impression that you would have us guess once at any point of the game and unless it was exactly right, you were out of the game for good. Or something. But it made sense the more I thought about it and I figured you meant that we're allowed one guess per 'game day' or whatever.

[Flying Mullet]

That's a good way of putting it; one guess per game day. You definitely need to be able to perform several guesses to solve the puzzle(from a logic puzzle standpoint, maybe you'll be a lucky punk).

EDIT: Actually, to help show how the game works, I'll close a game day right now, post the results and we'll start a new day. Hopefully that will help remove any confusion.

[Flying Mullet]

<b>Round One/Day One Results</b>
Rantzien: Fighter, Sword, Earth Cave - 2 correct
Aerith's Knight: White mage, mace, grudgy vulcano - 0 correct
Bunny: Black Mage, Axe, Sea Shrine - 1 correct
Psychotic: Red Mage, Club, Sky Castle - 0 correct
Levian: Black Mage, Mace, Sea Shrine - 1 correct
Momiji: White Mage, axe, Sky Castle - 0 correct
Loony BoB: Fighter, Sword, Gurgu Volcano - 1 correct
Mittopotahis: Red Mage, Mace, Sea Shrine - 0 correct

Game on!