Yeah, I can't decide if that's Gabranth or Basch. I mean, at what point in the stories' timelines are we? Clearly during the game, as all of these villains are still alive. Or is this totally and completely AU. Anyway, the judge is with Cosmos. So either he's a hero (Basch), or coming to cause mischief. I'm leaning more towards Gabranth, as Chaos needs an eleventh member.