Argh
I am at the library and my computer is about to run out of time, as I was reading through the posts I had missed...
I have to be brief haha

Zoidberg, didn't Fry get modkilled for being inactive???

Also the Nibbler-Fish thing, it could literally be a Red Herring.
Either the role he is is a Red Herring role
Or the hint is a red herring
arg
Times up