Quote Originally Posted by Del Murder View Post
Next question, when we see John the cylon is he supposed to be the same reverend guy who was on the fleet? Like the same copy. Do all the copies of him think and feel as he does or is he their leader? Do they share memories?
I think they all do share the same memories. Obviously not all the time, but they all do share the same personality and general thoughts so odds are they share memories at certain times the same way the Sharon's could download memories. It's still entirely possible that the John we see all the time is the first of them made and acts as something of a leader for them though.

What blew my mind was that he knew about the final 5 all along though, and erased the memories in the others at some point (apparently) to control them, and by extension, the Cylons so they could wipe out humanity. I doubt any of the others would have gone along with nuking the colonies had the five been there to talk them out of it. Probably why he was always so against finding the five. If the others knew who they were and what he did they might turn on him.