Quote Originally Posted by Noctiluca View Post
Hayden Christensen in the Star Wars prequels I would have preferred Jamie Bell (who played opposite Hayden in Jumper) to be Anakin. He's not as pretty, true, but Darth Vader never came off as a hottie to begin with.


Katie Holmes in Batman Begins. I don't think she was totally awful, but I also don't think she could compete with the big boys either.
The Hayden Christensen thing is most likely BECAUSE he was pretty though...and tall, since his story was supposed to be a love story (lawl) which admittedly should never take center stage in a SW movie at all, but here we are years later with two piles of fail anyway.

Katie Holmes has always been sucktacular to me.

If you tell me a movie or show, I can probably recast them on the fly xD But I can't think of any specific ones that I'd change off the top of my head.