Quote Originally Posted by Goldenboko View Post
Keep it. With the amount of money gamestop/ebgames/whatever has, they can lose out 50 bucks.
I work at GameStop and was originally gonna push towards "give it back", but I see massive amounts of truth to this. So it's really up to your conscience. Personally, after a couple hours or so of having the game in my hands, my own conscience would harden and I'd probably just keep it and go grab RE5 as well.