Quote Originally Posted by Levian View Post
Don't you need a female Good and a male Great to make one type and a male Good and a female Great to make the other type? I forget which is which, but to get the blue one it should be the opposite of what you've been mating.
Nope.

GreatF + GreatM + Carob Nut + combined total of 4 wins = 50% Blue, 50% Green

The order in which you choose the parents doesn't matter unless you're mating Black and Wonderful, as Marshall Banana said.

Quote Originally Posted by leader of mortals View Post
Ok but seriously, what is a way to reset the breeding mechanics?
Do something else. Leave the ranch, enter another area, fight some battles, then save. It may take a while, but it will eventually change.