Mafia XIII: Game thread! - GAME OVER - Hail to the Town!

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

My top suspect for today is FDR. I will now present the argument why. He was reluctant to vote for Teddy, and in fact tried to subtly stir people away from him. Illustrated by the following quotes:

Eisenhower is bugging me. His vote on Roosevelt is just to save his skin, and that seems odd seeing as he seems bent on contribution. Perhaps instead of panic voting, it would be wiser to look at other members and provide your opinion on them? Asking for contribution but not providing much is scummy, but there must be more reasons to lynch than that.

Not to say I'm not suspicious of Roosevelt though. I will keep my eye on you.

Trying to explain away Ike's vote on Teddy, but then says he will 'keep his eye' on Teddy. I didn't see any evidence of that since.

##Vote: Bill Clinton.

Now we're on evens for the most part. I think Eisenhower and Roosevelt should be given more time.

Giving your mafia buddy a chance, eh?

I think it's good to bandwagon at this point. If Bill is mafia he's going to try and do something. this way we can sort of flush him out I suppose.

I wouldn't say any bandwagons are good! Still, it's only day one I guess.

I would have ripped into Teddy if I saw that, and in fact I did. For a 'veteran smart player' he was too easy on him.

I believe Taft also bandwagoned, am I right?

This was in response to someone voting Teddy for bandwagoning. Trying to make Taft the suspect too?

I'm sorry Eisonhower, you were a good player. =)

Lies! Eisenhower was Laddy.

Bill Clinton, I'm calling you out. I want you to post your suspicions, explain why you wouldn't be guilty, and make up for yesterday. A townie was killed for you, and I'm certain that you will be lynched without hesitation if you fail to contribute.

Trying to influence us to continue after Clinton, a red herring.

Also, I do apologise for being defensive. It was the first vote against me, and that's enough to make anybody feel a little taken aback. I endorse voting earlier and looking for a final vote later, it makes more discussion and allows us to avoid non-voters

Reagan seems to know what he's doing, and I think he will be a pivotal member to the town, if he is so aligned. However, the paranoid side of me says this could be a ploy, and Reagan is distancing himself from Roosevelt. I'm more inclined towards thinking it is genuine suspicion, but when playing a game such as this everything must be taken into account. I only bring Reagan up because he seems like a powerful player, which is good, as long as he's town.

Two things. First he wasn't that defensive (he posted one sentence) so no need to apologize. Second he seems to be trying to get on my good side with compliments.

Yeah, I want to know as well. Seems odd that you would be so certain.

I agree. How can one truly know unless you are working together?

I didn't find Jefferson's remark all that odd, but for some reason three people in a row did. I'll give Bush Sr. some credit for saying it first. Notice how the Evil Leader said basically the same thing FDR did.

Reagan, are you sure you aren't being a tad harsh? Roosevelt is inconsistent and flippy floppy, but I don't get bad vibes from him. I suppose we're entitled to opinions though, and I can't say he's acting like a great town right now.

This is what made me start suspecting him. Uh, inconsistent and flippy floppy don't give you bad vibes? Isn't that how mafia act?

I regret the deleted post. I assure you it was me whining though. I was annoyed the day wasn't starting, but the hosts don't need any hassle.

And yes, thank you very much for pointing the "defensive" thing out to me. It makes me more suspicious of Jefferson.

Again, he wasn't that defensive and he should have noticed it at the beginning.

I fail to see the logic behind being suspected because of being an active poster. I post lots because I have a lot to share, and if I'm mafia because of that then that sucks. I also am certain of my vote for Jefferson now.

Ok, and then this with 4 minutes to go:

##Unvote: Jefferson
##Vote: Roosevelt.

Let's see what Roosevelt is then. If he's town, then we know who to watch out for tomorrow.

Teddy already had enough votes to be lynched. So with four minutes the only thing FDR would be doing was make sure he got his vote on a mafia member.

There you have it! What do you all think?