Can you be Overated and Underated at the same time?

[Wolf Kanno]

The word "overrated" lost it meaning a long time ago. Today, "overrated" is just a synonymous to "it's bad" or "it's sucks".
Most people use it, as just another form of insult.

I disagree a bit, I only use the word to describe things I feel really do get more attention than they deserve. I like VII but I feel its overrated, I like VI but I also feels its overrated. They are great games but it does get annoying listening to people talk about them like they are the Alpha and Omega of RPGs.

I don't feel I'm the only one who feels this way when I make this comment.

[The Crystal]

I disagree a bit, I only use the word to describe things I feel really do get more attention than they deserve. I like VII but I feel its overrated, I like VI but I also feels its overrated. They are great games but it does get annoying listening to people talk about them like they are the Alpha and Omega of RPGs.

I don't feel I'm the only one who feels this way when I make this comment.

Then you could be an exception. After all, I was talking about most people, not all.
But what I said is just something based on my personal experiences. I can be totally wrong.