I just realized that I completely misread the first post, so now I have to write a new one since my first one has nothing to do with the question.

Quote Originally Posted by Wolf Kanno View Post
Zemus: Now don't get me wrong, I like Zemus and I enjoy his motive and reasoning but I do feel they waited far too long to reveal him. He's just outshined by Golbez.
I hate these last-minute throw-in villains. This was the same issue I had with Necron, though they were much worse with it when it came to Necron.

Quote Originally Posted by Wolf Kanno View Post
Seymour: Chatty villain who is more of an annoyance than a threat. It gets downright laughable towards the end of the game. He could easily be written out of the plot and it wouldn't really affect the games plot too dramatically (hell make it 10 hours shorter which is a bonus for this game).
I don't think I've spoken to anyone that actually likes Seymour.

Quote Originally Posted by Wolf Kanno View Post
Shuyin (FFX-2) and Genesis (FFVII: CC): When bad guys feel like people I went to high school with I feel we have a problem. Shuyin whines around about a lost love despite the fact its his own damn fault they got killed and still feels the world should pay? Whiny loser is more like it. Then you have Genesis who feels like a emo kid mixed with the more deranged VII fanboys who whines around about how he isn't as cool as Sephiroth and spout terrible poetry at the drop of a hat... Genesis makes Sephiroth down right respectable. I could easily nickname both of them after people I knew in high school and that just makes them outright laughable in my book.
Goodness. I never really had the motivation to play this game, but when you put it like that...

Alright so here goes my list:

Zeromus
Necron

And my list ends up being not very much different from my original one. Alright, so you can nit-pick and tear down every shoddy villain as Wolf Kanno has, but I think I'll just limit my selection down to the absolute worst-of-the-worst. Ultimecia and Sephiroth sorta tie for me in terms of being poor villains, but they still aren't nearly as bad as Necron and Zeromus are for obvious reasons.