Thanks guys!

Oh man, they sold a bunch of these buttons to a pack at Jo-Ann, Shlup. They're soooo cute.

And you'd be surprised. You don't sew the two top flaps together until the end, which you stick the ends of the ribbon into so that it stays together discreetly, which is why you can see the stitches on the top of it, since you don't do it inside out. But I couldn't figure it out for the LIFE of me. I kept sewing it on top of the flap, and on the bottom, kept having to rip seams, until I was like "Oh wait..." xD