No you are not weird, there is some really good music out there, something that I think is hard to find today, a whole album that you love and can listen to fully without skipping.

My first thought of great game soundstracks was Secret of Mana. I can listen to that soundtrack from start finish no skipping, every track is brilliant. Every track I can image a certain place in the game, listening to the soundtrack is like playing the game over again. Just abosolute brilliance, it is the only game soundtrack I legally own, had it imported from Japan.

For the Final Fantasy soundtracks, I would have to say for overall whole soundtrack would have to IX for me. I dont love every track on it, but most. Having replayed IX over the last couple of weeks it brings back a lot of memories and appreciate a lot more music. But the classic off that soundtrack for me would have to be the opening theme "The Place I Will Return to Someday" that song is just amazing so sad and powerful.
However the first time I saw "Suteki Da Ne" in X I feel in love with it, just fitted the scene perfectly, and the strong violin really is heartbreaking, I get really emotional listening just to violin of that track.