Quote Originally Posted by Ryushikaze
Quote Originally Posted by Serapy View Post
We don't have magic in reality, but we can have clothes.If VIII has magic that can create anything, it wouldn't make sense if they use clothes for thier appearances.
Yes. Yes it would make perfect sense to use clothing instead of constantly wasting their energy like that.
Ultimecia's used a huge amount of energy travelling through time. So, I don't see why not.

Quote Originally Posted by Ryushikaze
No, I was trying to use an analogy.
Instead of answering my direct request to prove it, you offered an analogy. You did not offer proof. Again, I say, you made it up. Analogies do not substantiate extraordinary claims.
I never once said or claimed that they are absolutely the same thing.

Quote Originally Posted by Ryushikaze
It's silly and wrong to claim proof that two identical arts are just... that identical to each other.

VIII is not something that's 100% fool proof. Claiming proof on something other than dialogues is ridiculous.
Identical art? I'm seeing more claiming and still no proving, Serapy...
You have used common sense to claim something in VIII (Cid loving Edea), so why not apply the same sense to the art works? Use your eyes, my friend. Even then, you have claimed that they don't alike. It's still illogical to ask for proof that they are actually alike.

Quote Originally Posted by Ryushikaze
Git is a 'noun' and provides the meaning of 'a person, especially a man, who is stupid or unpleasant'.

Disingenuous is an adjective, and can be used with any noun. Hence, you called me a disingenuous git. That's name calling, or a personal attack.
No, it was a summation of you acting disingenuous by really valid point and i'm impressed by your thinking.ning, and of your unpleasant attitude.
I beg to differ. Your attitude is a bit worse, me thinks.


Quote Originally Posted by Ryushikaze
You've called me strange names - such words that don't exist on the dictionary. The answer is obvious, isn't it?
That I find your arguments specious, your attitude infuriating and insane, and your demeanor unpleasant, and I make no bones about hiding any of this?
Honestly, if you knew what would happen after accusing me being a troll, why feel the need to keep arguing?

I think there's a conspiracy to all of this. When Squall of Seed, Sir B and TOK started appearing out of no where, you came on.

Quote Originally Posted by Ryushikaze
I'm not claiming anything, my friend.
Either you're lying, in which case, my calling you disingenuous is fully warranted, or you aren't you have absolutely no idea what you're doing.
I have no idea what am I doing. Please elaborate?

Quote Originally Posted by Ryushikaze
I'm not going into a circle and repeat that something must be true.
Circular reasoning, dweller, is arguing using a conclusion in support of itself. In this instance, arguing that Edea's appearance changing gradually instead of suddenly is only evidence of your claim that Ultimecia's power changed Edea and that there is still a piece of Ultimecia inside Edea if you assume those things to be true. Otherwise, there are far simpler, far more parsimonious explanations for Edea's appearance which do not require magic cosmetics and using magic instead of clothes.
I think Rinoa broke that circle... since her appearance didn't change when she was captive of Ultimecia.