Ridiculus Debate of the century!

[blackmage_nuke]

Let us say theoretically you have a perfect sphere and you are using it as a dice, would it be a D1 or a D∞?

Ie:
If you were to use a sphere as a dice would you consider it a one sided dice (always rolls the number 1) or an infinite sided dice (can roll any positive integer)

Suggested arguements:
A D∞ is impossible
A D1 is useless

[Shoeberto]

Assuming it was actually, by some magic, a perfect sphere, it would be an infinity sided die, imo.

[qwertysaur]

Yes

[Madame Adequate]

Both.

[Aerith's Knight]

It would be infinite, and infinitely useless.

[Vermachtnis]

I'd roll a one with the infinite dice.

[Bunny]

I would just throw it at people.

[Old Manus]

A theoretically perfect sphere would have theoretically one side as there would be no minute flat areas which would constitute a seperate side

[G13]

I say infinity but what do I know, I'm a moron.

[Raistlin]

Assuming it was actually, by some magic, a perfect sphere, it would be an infinity sided die, imo.

Yeah. A sphere by definition contains infinite points.

[qwertysaur]

And the probability of getting a specific side is 1/∞ which is 0

[Levian]

You can't write infinity numbers on a dice Not if you want to use it anyway.

[AntRid]

Can you have a 1 sided die? Wouldn’t that just be a lotto ball?

[Rantz]

It depends on how tiny numbers you can paint.

[blackmage_nuke]

Well they would have to be infinitely small and you would have to believe a sphere is made up of infinite flat surfaces with infinitesimal areas rather than having no flat surfaces at all