So town is not dead. There's only four possibilities for this.

1. Ifrit got roleblocker last night which is the only one he hasn't gotten so far if I am remembering correctly and he blocked the Cult Leader from recruiting.
2. I roleblocked the Cult Leader.
3. I protected the right person.
4. Cult tried to recruit someone who was unrecruitable and wasted a day. This may apply to if they tried to recruit Shiva.