An FFXIV site - I would be stunned if a place like IGN got 75% of their members saying it was exciting because most gamers don't give a about Final Fantasy, MMORPGs and if they are into MMORPGs or Final Fantasy, they usually are into WoW / single player FF's respectively.
FFXIVCore was the site. It's full of people who are criticising the game but still 75% are excited. I thought that was pretty good, personally.